TWO DADS. FACE-OFF: Andrey Stavnitser and Volodymyr Lavrenchuk
Volodymyr Lavrenchuk and Andrey Stavnitser
Owning your own business or being responsible for someone else’s? Whose job is harder — the CEO’s or the owner’s? Who works more? And who is more important to the business? It is perhaps one of those chicken-or-egg questions.
That is precisely why Huxley finds it so fascinating. Obviously, each side in this philosophical debate will stand its ground. The CEO believes that all the real work rests on their shoulders. The owner knows that without them, there would be no CEO. Curiously enough, both are probably right.
So we decided to conduct an experiment — to arrange a kind of “face-off” between two exceptionally interesting and multifaceted people: one, an enormously experienced CEO from the banking sector; the other, the owner of a major business. Andrey Stavnitser and Volodymyr Lavrenchuk.
Co-owner of Ukraine’s largest port and the long-serving Chairman of the Management Board of Raiffeisen Bank Aval.
A shareholder who spent 13 years as CEO of his own business. And a CEO who held a senior position at a huge bank for more than 14 years, steering it through two global crises.
Andrey Stavnitser (A.S.): To be honest, this is the first time I’ve ever interviewed anyone.
Volodymyr Lavrenchuk (V.L.): Same here.
A.S.: So, as a warm-up, I suggest we take turns answering the same questions. Shall we?
Do you have a signature question you ask job candidates during interviews?
V.L.: I ask: where are you from? Interestingly, people are usually embarrassed by the place where they were born. The usual answer is: “I’ve been in Kyiv for six months now.” And I immediately understand that “eins-zwei-drei” doesn’t work. We hear one thing and talk about another. It is a simple test of a person’s ability to hear the question and answer it directly. And when I find out that someone is, say, from Kamianka, I start asking further questions: what is interesting about the place, why is it called that? And the person doesn’t know. If a person doesn’t know their own roots, that is an alarming sign. Among other things, it says something about the breadth of their outlook.
A.S.: Yes, I always ask: if you didn’t have to earn money, what would you do? And the person just stares at me blankly. Then I say: imagine your grandmother died and left you Ocean Plaza — Vasyl Khmelnytsky, I’m just using it as an example. What would you do? And three quarters of the answers are something along the lines of, “I’d invest.” I say: why? You already receive rental income every month. What would you do every day? Where would you go? The answers are always very interesting.
What was your most difficult and significant decision of the past ten years?
V.L.: I’ll talk about something positive. It is not typical for the CEO of an international bank to communicate extensively with clients. But I managed to do it, and I think I gained a great deal from making that kind of communication an almost daily practice. It was interesting, useful, and extremely positive in every respect.
A.S.: The most difficult decision? I made it recently. I decided to step down as CEO of the TIS Group after 13 years. And it is an interesting experience, because you voluntarily give up a great many levers of control that you have become accustomed to over so many years.
V.L.: If we are talking about a difficult period, then it was certainly 2008: the crisis, negative assessments from investors… And in a situation like that, you have to leave. No one was pushing me out, but I felt that people were dissatisfied with me. And I read in Jack Welch’s recommendations that if there is no rapport with the shareholders, it is better to leave. But after reading the book, I thought: I’m going to try! And it took me two years to restore a positive relationship.
What are the most important words you should say to your child at the ages of five, ten, and fifteen?
V.L.: I don’t have any special words. I think the most important thing is to demonstrate your integrity every single day.
A.S.: There is this silly saying that until the age of five you are a king, until ten you are a servant, and after that — a friend… I took my children out of school and switched them to homeschooling six months ago. And the changes are simply astonishing. They are no longer inhibited; they are curious, and they open up more and more every day.
Have people changed over the time you have been in business?
A.S.: Those notorious millennials have appeared, and I still have no idea how to communicate with them. I’m completely hopeless at it, no matter how many books I read! Everything I grew up with simply doesn’t work with them. I understand financial motivation, career motivation, reputation, standing, and so on. But when a person doesn’t need any of that — they don’t need an apartment, a trip to Bali is inexpensive, and they don’t need to buy a car either — they behave in ways I simply cannot understand. For example, they can just turn around and walk away at any moment. We recently held a two-day conference and hired a 20-year-old girl to work at reception. She went out for lunch and texted us straight from the café: “Sorry, I’m not feeling it, I’m out.” Another girl, in a similar situation, disappeared for three days and then wrote: “Don’t count on me, I’m in Bali.” And I have no idea what to do about that. Maybe you do?
V.L.: I recently moderated a meeting devoted precisely to this issue. It was called “Millennials vs. Old-School Managers.” And after two hours I left disappointed because, even as the moderator, I still couldn’t grasp the essence of it. What I understood least was when a very successful young man, about 20 years old, talked about how easily he fires employees if they fail to meet a certain KPI. Based on the principle of “I do not care.” I don’t share that attitude.
A.S.: Neither do I. Maybe you hired the person for the wrong job? Maybe you interviewed them badly? Maybe they would be more useful somewhere else?
V.L.: That’s exactly what I mean. Millennials demonstrate this kind of pragmatism, but I think it will pass.
A.S.: We need to think not about how to fire more people, but about how to hire more. Otherwise, what are all those people who have been fired supposed to do?

V.L.: Yes! And whenever I heard reports that another 4,000 people had been cut from the bank, it made me sad. I’m not saying that I’m somehow morally superior. Unfortunately, I simply couldn’t find another solution.
What would you recommend investing in?
V.L.: If you have money to spare, you should invest in what you love, what interests you, and what you see a future in. In Ukraine today, there are almost no investment financial instruments in which to place your money. Against this backdrop, people will have little choice: they will take risks and invest in their own businesses, because only their own businesses will generate income. There will be more small shops, restaurants, cafés, barbershops. And that is a good thing.
A.S.: I would invest in food. Soon there will be 10 billion of us on Earth, and everyone needs to eat. Yes, there will be some kind of new food, perhaps synthetic — but it will be needed regardless. And given millennials’ attitudes, investing in real estate, oil, or even alcohol is a thing of the past. Luxury goods have completely disappeared. You may have billions of dollars, but you wear exactly the same watch as a guy on the street. In 2019, Apple Watch sold 10 million more units than all Swiss brands combined. The world has changed. Fashion may survive for a while longer, but I don’t think it will last very long. It seems to me that healthcare and food are the things worth investing in.
A.S.: Volodymyr, you were the CEO of a major bank for a long time. Didn’t you ever want to try creating your own business?
V.L.: I find the atmosphere of having your own brand, your own company, extremely appealing. Even if it were poultry farming or crop production. And to some extent I envy people who have created their own brands. So I’ll be very interested to hear what you have to say.
A.S.: Then let me rephrase it. When you are an entrepreneur on your own, you bear the responsibility. When you are part of a large organization, not only do you have a safety margin, you also have professionals from different fields who can strengthen you. Tell me, is there a certain thrill in that?
V.L.: Absolutely! It gives you a foundation for making decisions. Especially when it comes to tactics: products, how they are structured, the pace at which they are introduced. That is an obvious advantage compared with entrepreneurs who have nowhere to turn except Google or people they know.
A.S.: By temperament, some people are employees and some are entrepreneurs. Do you have that kind of conflict within yourself?
V.L.: I don’t have that struggle. I’ve been in the sector for 36 years. I’ve lived through several political regimes, starting with the Central Committee. And that toughened me. Then there were the crises of 1998, 2008, and 2014. I have a very strong sense of responsibility toward depositors in my blood. I remember how, in 1998, I used to peek around the corner of the building to see whether there was a queue outside the bank, because the bank didn’t have enough cash to return people’s deposits. I remember how I felt, and I told myself then that I would never go back to that situation. I made it a rule: there must always be cash in the bank. So that no matter what fluctuations occur, a depositor can come to the bank and get their money.
A.S.: You’re talking about personal responsibility. Does it still exist even though you are part of a group?
V.L.: Yes. That is simply my nature. At the same time, I understand that my own income could never cover the collapse of a bank with two million depositors. So my responsibility can only be legal and moral, not financial.
A.S.: And what if you were running your own business?
V.L.: I’m going to disappoint you. I don’t have an answer to that question.
A.S.: Which kind of responsibility weighs more heavily on you personally — losing a few thousand dollars of your own money, or letting 50,000 people down? That is a big question. For me, it is much easier to lose my own money than to be responsible to an enormous number of people.
V.L.: That is very subjective. Everyone measures it according to their own experience. It seems funny now, but when the market was small and the deals were small, whenever I signed a deal I would measure its value against the price of my apartment. It really is funny to remember now — billion-dollar deals on the one hand, and an apartment on Zhytomyrska Street on the other!

A.S.: And yet, do you feel a need to have your own business?
V.L.: I sometimes ask myself that question. For example, would I work in another country? And I came up with this answer: it just so happened that I am a “dinosaur” in the industry, and I was fortunate enough to be in the right place at the right time — including at Raiffeisen. I have accumulated a great deal of knowledge, and it seems unjustifiable to simply let it go to waste. Another thing is that I have a hobby that now has its own brand. And to a very small extent, that shapes my sense that I have an entrepreneurial venture of my own. It is non-commercial, but it is entrepreneurial. My friends and I created a musical and toured with it for four years, even taking it to Toronto — very successfully. So I know the entrepreneurial state of mind very well. But that doesn’t mean I’m changing industries.
A.S.: Not everything is measured in money. There are emotional dividends too. But could it ever happen that you become completely fed up with banking and say: that’s it, I don’t want this anymore? I want to be a producer, or sell something — glasses, shaving accessories.
V.L.: Pavlo Sheremeta once asked me the same thing in a similar conversation: don’t you want to drop all of this and focus on promoting the musical? I thought about it. Yes, I do it, and I enjoy it. But it doesn’t take up all my time. It is simply something that gives me pleasure. Incidentally, the greatest satisfaction I have had from work in recent years did not come from issuing loans. It came from seeing young, talented people become better than you. I know several young people like that — they are simply brilliant. And when you remember them as students, how they grew up in front of you or partly alongside you, and you can continue to influence that growth — that is incredibly rewarding. It is not so much about closing deals yourself as seeing someone who grew up before your eyes closing those deals. I become happier when I am surrounded by happy people. And when people grow, they are happy.
A.S.: One theory says that the Russian word for happiness, schastye, comes from the idea of “being made of parts,” of bringing parts together. The idea is that you cannot be happy simply because you are rich or live in a mansion. Everything has to be in harmony. If you imagine a wheel, its spokes — friends, career, family, hobbies — need to be in some kind of balance. If even one of those things is in the red, then that happiness, that sense of the parts coming together, will not exist.
V.L.: I’m going to seize on that last phrase. I have not managed to find balance. My own experience tells me that if you have a passion, especially a professional one, it consumes all your time. You remain involved in the business process — deals are urgent, while the family can wait. I heard more than just your explanation of what happiness is. I know you by now, and I also sense harmony in you.
Do you consider yourself a balanced person? If so, have there been periods when the different components of happiness were in conflict?
A.S.: At every stage of life, something falls behind. At one point it is work, then health, then something happens in the family. It is dynamic. It is like juggling balls. You constantly have to keep the “career,” “family,” and “work” balls in the air. The moment you stop, something begins to fall. You cannot completely forget about any one of them.
V.L.: You went to work in the family business when you were still very young. Was it difficult?
A.S.: It was. I had absolutely no experience working for other companies, and I found myself immediately in an environment where people were biased against me from the outset. After all, I was the founder’s son. And I was extremely ambitious. I desperately wanted to be appreciated for what I was worth, rather than judged by some other criteria. You have to understand that TIS is a company full of people with engineering backgrounds — highly educated, highly intelligent people, each in their particular field. And earning their respect is quite difficult. They are 20 or 25 years older than you. And I was like that little frog, desperately paddling away. I wanted to see their genuine attitude toward me. And it was very difficult. I remember that period very well. For me, it was entirely dominated by work, with none of the other components of life.
V.L.: Was there an event, a particular day, when you felt you had achieved something and those people finally saw that you were capable of doing more than others?
A.S.: I simply became part of the team. There was no sudden moment when, with the snap of a finger, they started respecting me, patted me on the shoulder, and had a drink with me. I simply became part of the team gradually, little by little.
V.L.: That episode of yours reminds me of my own story with English. That is a whole separate subject. When I worked at Oschadbank, I earned $18 a month, while an English lesson cost $7 an hour. And being a banker, I asked someone to find me a teacher. They did. She interviewed me and named her price: $7 an hour… I thanked her, said I couldn’t afford it, and she advised me to read in English every day. She said the light bulb might not switch on yet, but one day it would. And one day it really did. I don’t even remember the exact moment, but one day I simply stopped experiencing difficulties. It was about focusing on the result every single day… Let’s get back to you. Okay, you had the family company where you gained your experience. But you also studied a lot, didn’t you?
A.S.: Today my son comes to me and says: I want to study business. I tell him: how lucky you are to have me! Because I wanted to study business too. And I wasted a year and a half of my life on an MBA. It was an enormous, colossal mistake! I did it when I was 18 and wasted my time. Today, I would tell my 18-year-old self: dude, go and get a qualification in something you actually like. Business is an applied discipline. Get a specialized education, learn the field you enjoy — and then learn business. It cannot be your first education.
Do you have moments like that? What would you tell your 18-year-old self?
V.L.: I would advise myself to dream more. Because we didn’t dream enough. I started out back in the Soviet era. So there were few desires, little imagination. My degree is in Finance and Credit. Simply because my friends were going to study it, so I went too. Because there was simply no imagination.
A.S.: How many IT specialists were there in Ukraine ten years ago? A couple of thousand, perhaps. Today there are 150,000. It is a $7 billion industry. Where did they study? Nowhere! They learned at home on their computers because they were highly motivated. Do you really need to spend five years sitting at a university? In this context, I really like an illustration from The Wall Street Journal showing children sitting in a classroom with light bulbs instead of heads. And at the desk sits a teacher with a candle instead of a head. In many ways, it reflects our reality: antiquated, prehistoric teaching methods that simply do not fit children’s minds.
V.L.: I have a question that is slightly off-topic. Are you an Odesa patriot?
A.S.: Are we buying or selling? (laughs)
V.L.: I have spent time in different environments — Kyiv, Lviv, Odesa — and Odesa is the one I cannot explain. Culturally, it is all very unusual.
When I see you in Kyiv, you remind me of the line from Sting’s song, “…Be yourself no matter what they say” (Englishman in New York). How do you feel operating in different markets?
A.S.: Thank you, I like the question. If we are talking about Odesa, it is a very inward-looking city. The Odesa crowd is extremely reluctant to accept outsiders. We can see what happens with mayors and governors — they simply don’t take root. It is very difficult to impose outsiders on Odesa. From a business perspective, there are peculiarities too. If you learn how to work with Odesans and make money with them, you will be able to make money anywhere in the world. They focus not only on making money, but on how to make it. They are very commercially minded people. Why, for example, was a Maidan in Odesa hardly possible, and why did so few people believe it could happen? Because the mentality is commercial: “Oh, so I go there — and then what? What if everything changes tomorrow and they end up accusing me of something? I’ll wait.” And the whole city thinks like that. About politicians of every possible stripe. So whoever comes to us with a sword — we’ll buy it from him (laughs).
In the spring of 2014, the city was on the verge of breaking away, just like Donetsk and Luhansk. There was every chance of it happening. People approached law enforcement officers and officials, showed them folders and said: guys, the time will soon come when all you have to do is nothing. Just sit quietly, and everything will be fine. The fact that the city ultimately swung toward the Ukrainian side was an enormous stroke of luck and the achievement of a small number of people. Back then, nobody understood anything. Nobody knew what would happen in a week or a month. There was a moment of confusion. Donetsk had just happened, and Crimea before that. Nobody knew whether things would get better or worse. Everyone knew that Russia was a large country with a strong army, economy, salaries, and pensions. And some people genuinely thought that perhaps we would be better off there.
There is a weapons depot in Odesa with an enormous number of Kalashnikov rifles, pistols, and ammunition. And the whole place was guarded by just a few people. I remember a moment when civic-minded Odesans went to guard such facilities, armed with whatever hunting rifles they could find. That kind of self-defense made an enormous positive difference for the city. I am very grateful to all the people who did it. Today everyone understands what is happening. Back then, it was a huge question mark. Today the city is developing. It took Odesans time to shift from wealthy Russian tourists to Ukrainians, Poles, and so on. It was very difficult. Everyone was accustomed to something different. Now you have to compete for the mass-market tourist, for the repeat customer, by offering them the very best.
V.L.: Why did you decide to open your own restaurant?
A.S.: For many years, I essentially sat around as a caretaker at the port. Everyone thinks a port is all maritime romance: you watch the seagulls, the sea, the little ships, while Utyosov sings away in the office next door. In reality, I sat in an office overlooking a mineral fertilizer warehouse — dusty, with piles of rusty scrap metal everywhere. After a while, I got tired of it. I went to my brother and said: listen, let’s create a place where we can meet guests, have a proper meal, and talk. That is how the Fratelli restaurant was born.
We built it ourselves. We had no managers, no partners — we did it ourselves. My wife Diana and I designed it and did everything else. When the idea came to us, everyone knew that the best restaurateur in this field was Serhiy Husovsky. I didn’t know him, but I went to Kyiv, met him and said: we have a restaurant, come and take a look at it; maybe you’ll agree to manage it. He agreed to have a look.
So they came to Odesa and looked at the place. Serhiy said: “It’s a good location. You need to invest, say, $100 in it.” I said: “Serhiy, I understand you’re from the capital and all, but we were thinking of investing $30, maybe $40 at most. After all, it’s an operating Greek restaurant — where does $100 come from?” He said: “Do as you like, but I can’t accomplish what you want for less than $100.” We scratched our heads and decided to do the restaurant ourselves.
And when we had spent $180 on it, we looked each other in the eye and thought that Serhiy really did know something and really had been right. But by then it was too awkward to call him. We spent twice as much as Serhiy had estimated — naturally, because of our lack of experience. I try to rely on the opinions of authoritative people, and Husovsky’s opinion mattered to me.
After that, I invited him to the restaurant several times — to the opening and just to visit. He never came. A year passed. I walked into the restaurant one day and saw Husovsky sitting quietly at a table having dinner. No phone call, nothing. I was like a contestant on MasterChef — sitting there, waiting. Then, around midnight, I received a message: “Andrey, my compliments. You pulled it off.” For me, that was the most meaningful praise imaginable. I remembered it for the rest of my life.
V.L.: We both have extremely busy schedules. What kinds of things consume the most energy during your week?
A.S.: While I’m thinking, may I turn that question back on you?
V.L.: A great deal of energy went into building effective interaction. It is important, but quite often it was difficult to establish. Different management cultures, a failure to accept different forms of communication, different levels of depth in argumentation, and ultimately the way a task or decision is formulated. The ability to “listen and truly hear” came with time. Once, I had a conflict with an Austrian executive. He was undoubtedly intelligent and very experienced, but he was a real martinet: “It will be exactly as I said: eins-zwei-drei — period!” It did not happen immediately, but over time I reached an understanding with him by switching to extremely specific arguments in the same “eins-zwei-drei” style — and everything began to work…
For years, I also found it difficult to rid myself of the bad habit of taking disagreement with my point of view personally, as disagreement with me as a person. That wasted an enormous amount of energy. Eventually, the rule “Nothing personal, just business!” greatly improved my professional life. Of course, things became different when I was potentially nominated for the National Bank.
A.S.: Do you regret not going to the National Bank?
V.L.: When it didn’t happen, I entered a very happy period with Raiffeisen: my relationship with the shareholders became completely different, and the bank was in very good shape. By the way, a question for you: would you like to work for an international company with a huge number of procedures, but also a head office? Would you enter that procedural world?
A.S.: That is a really great question. I ask myself that often because I work with multinational corporations. What excites me is the scale of what can be accomplished with the resources they have. Take any major corporation: colossal resources, colossal connections, networks all over the world, the scale of the projects. I am far less motivated by my own personal gain than by the scale of the projects I could accomplish with resources like that.
The fact that you have to report to someone is a big question — whether I would be ready to report to someone after so many years of working independently. But I do have experience with partnerships, even if they were not quite so hierarchical. Here is a real-life example involving Cargill. Our contract with them is 900 pages of English text. When we were negotiating, most of the clauses made us want to ask: “Are you serious? Most of what you are insisting on is never going to happen!” We agreed to most of their demands because we believed none of those things would ever materialize. And what do you think? By the time the terminal was launched, 30% of all those things had actually happened! And we scratched our heads and said: “Yes, guys, in 157 years you really have learned a thing or two.” It is the same here: yes, it is bureaucratic, it is slow, but once you get moving, you keep going for decades.
V.L.: If you wouldn’t mind working within a corporate system, perhaps the next step is government?
A.S.: Not quite. There is so much dirt and intrigue there…
V.L.: Do you remember the first person you ever fired?
A.S.: Yes. I fired a construction worker, a particularly nasty guy who was cheating me on a small project. It was incredibly difficult and emotionally exhausting. I remember where it happened, how it happened, when it happened, what everyone was wearing. It is probably one of those rare occasions I remember down to the smallest detail. I was 19 or 20.
V.L.: And I remember the terrible process of reducing a bank workforce from 20,000 people to 8,000. In just a few years — minus 12,000 people. Emotionally, that experience overshadows virtually everything else I have experienced. It is also extremely difficult to fire friends. You do make friends at work. Generally speaking, that is not necessarily a good thing, but friendships do develop.
A.S.: As I understand it, you loved your work. What is love to you?
V.L.: If you approach everything with love, it shows immediately. Even in banking. Doing something with love is a great pleasure. I disagree with the idea that meetings are boring. Sometimes people are tense, aggressive, or lack belief… I have rarely seen people succeed in that state, so I always — or rather, often — intervene in the process, asking again, reassessing: do we really want to do this? I ask myself the same question. As a rule, there is always something beyond formal KPIs, and very often it is YOUR CLIENTS. They appreciate it when things are done with love. Let me draw a parallel: I play a little rock and roll. You can feel the support of your band behind you, and you will only truly start playing when everyone loves the music..
When copying materials, please place an active link to www.huxley.media
Select the text and press Ctrl + Enter