SUPERPOWER AND THE REBELLION OF AN UNCOMFORTABLE GENIUS: He Made Black Holes Real

Sir Roger Penrose (born August 8, 1931) is an English mathematician, philosopher of science, and Nobel laureate in physics. He is an emeritus professor of mathematics at the University of Oxford, an honorary fellow of Wadham College and St. John’s College, Cambridge, as well as University College London. / pioneerworks.org

This year, Nobel laureate, British physicist, and mathematician Roger Penrose turned 93. He is a living legend of modern science. And despite his esteemed status as a «classic», he remains full of the most daring ideas. Patchen Barss’ book The Impossible Man: Roger Penrose and the Price of Genius is dedicated to the biography of this remarkable scientist — the creator of black hole theory, a man whom some consider almost a demigod.

THE PRICE OF GENIUS

oger Penrose is an iconic figure in modern mathematical physics. He is one of the few surviving pioneers who helped shape the black hole theory. With extraordinary intellectual abilities, Penrose is an exceptionally influential and charismatic figure — yet endlessly controversial.

And how could it be otherwise when his primary tools of understanding have always been visual imagination and artistry? These gifts have brought him worldwide fame. The central theme of his biography is the contemplation of the price one must pay for genius — a price not only the genius himself must bear but also those around him.

IN THE BEGINNING… THERE WERE GENES

Penrose was born in 1931 in Colchester, United Kingdom, into a family of remarkable intellectuals. His father, the geneticist Lionel Penrose, was a man of extraordinary intellect but was almost entirely devoid of emotional intelligence. He remained distant from his four children, engaging with them solely through intellectual activities such as chess, logic games, or mathematical exercises.

In addition, Lionel was obsessively controlling of his wife, Margaret. She was a qualified doctor, yet her husband forbade her from practicing medicine. As a result, Margaret withdrew into herself, and Roger grew up in an environment of emotional neglect from both parents. This upbringing would later influence his own relationships with his children and his first wife, Joan Wedge.

THE FIRST REBELLION

From an early age, Roger displayed an extraordinary inclination for geometric constructions. However, his father regarded his son’s fascination with suspicion. He believed that professional mathematicians were eccentric and detached from the real world. Thus, Lionel Penrose wanted Roger to grow up «normal», study medicine, and become a doctor.

But Roger rebelled, defying his father’s wishes for the first time. The world may have lost a potentially good doctor, but it certainly gained a genius in mathematical physics. He immersed himself entirely in mathematics. Initially, it was his sole interest, but everything changed in the 1950s.

While studying at University College London and later at Cambridge, Penrose encountered Albert Einstein’s general theory of relativity. Soon after, he turned his attention to quantum physics, attending lectures by another Nobel laureate, Paul Dirac.

INTUITION AS A SUPERPOWER

Penrose possessed a kind of «superpower» that defined his entire scientific career — an extraordinarily developed spatial intuition. He applied this unique ability to perceive the world geometrically in his approach to physics.

His ideas were not so much the result of meticulous calculations as they were the product of sudden «insights» — he had a remarkable talent for quickly seeing what others overlooked. Today, most mathematicians and physicists worldwide are familiar with his concepts.

For example, Penrose diagrams allow us to visualize the past, present, and future of the universe. Meanwhile, his tensor networks have become a fundamental tool in machine learning.

THE MATHEMATICAL DANCE

One of these «insights» occurred in 1963 during a trip to Texas. From that moment on, the development of twistor theory became the central theme of his scientific work. With this concept, Penrose sought to reconcile two previously incompatible principles — quantum mechanics and general relativity.

Twistors are an entirely new type of object — purely abstract and mathematical, with no physical form. Penrose’s wit was unmistakable: the word twist referred to a dance that had become wildly popular in the early 1960s.

At the core of the twistor concept, which characterizes the relationship between space and time, Penrose incorporated complex numbers.

THE «TWISTED» WORLD

From basic school mathematics, we know that extracting the square root of a negative number is mathematically incorrect. However, if one dares to do it, the result is imaginary or complex numbers. Penrose was fascinated by them because they helped solve seemingly impossible equations. The algebra of complex numbers found its most natural expression in the geometric symmetry of curves on a sphere.

Penrose’s twistors gave these ideas a deeper meaning, redefining every point in space-time as a complex sphere.

Of course, science is still far from an absolute understanding of how this «twisted world» truly works. But Penrose pointed the way forward, inspiring generations of twistorians who continue to seek a reconciliation between gravity and quantum physics.

BETWEEN CANON AND HERESY

Penrose’s mathematical ideas have become an integral part of theoretical physics. However, with his exceptional spatial imagination, he produced a torrent of ideas — many of which were either ignored or ridiculed by his peers. Yet, Penrose was nothing if not persistent.

In 2020, he was awarded the Nobel Prize. His laureate lecture, traditionally delivered by every recipient, was a balancing act between orthodoxy and radicalism. In the first ten minutes, he briefly summarized the theory for which he received the prize — Namely, a mathematical scenario in which the inevitable collapse of a star distorts space-time so profoundly that it paradoxically breaks the very theory that predicts it. This idea was truly revolutionary.

THE BIG BANG — NOT IN THE PAST, BUT IN THE FUTURE?

But that was just the prelude. The remaining 30 minutes of his Nobel lecture were dedicated to promoting his cyclic cosmology, which he elaborated on in his 2010 book Cycles of Time. The more the scientific community ignored it, the more stubbornly Penrose defended his theory.

According to him, the Big Bang, while real, is merely a matter of perspective. The universe will continue expanding, stretching, and cooling until the very concepts of space and time lose all meaning. This will create the conditions for a new Big Bang and a new cycle of expansion — repeating endlessly.

CONSCIOUSNESS — A QUANTUM PHENOMENON?

Yet, Penrose’s cosmological theory, while controversial, is not considered his most radical idea. Even more provocative were the arguments he presented in his 1989 bestseller The Emperor’s New Mind. In this book, Penrose argues that human consciousness is the result of quantum processes in the brain.

Widespread skepticism from the scientific community only made him more determined. His journey in science began as a rebellion against his father’s wishes — and continued as a rebellion against what he saw as the overly rigid thinking of mainstream academia.

Penrose worked hard to find like-minded thinkers, though with little success.

THE GENIUS REBEL

The scientist was notoriously resistant to any disagreement with his ideas — so much so that this trait may have contributed to the end of his marriage to Vanessa Thomas, his former doctoral student.

Nevertheless, the brilliant Penrose has excelled not only in mathematical physics but also in longevity. Who knows what other unconventional ideas he may yet surprise us with? It may take decades to prove or disprove his theories.

But imagine the sheer scale of his genius if he turns out to be right. As Penrose himself puts it: «The universe is out of its mind. A normal person cannot understand it!»

Original research: