Menu
For joint projects editor@huxley.media
For cooperation with authors chiefeditor@huxley.media
Telephone

SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT by Chandran Nair: “China’s Green Pearl”

Huxley
Author: Huxley
© Huxley – an almanac about philosophy, art and science
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT by Chandran Nair: “China’s Green Pearl”
Chandran Nair. Photo by Anatol Kotte / Art design: huxley.media via Photoshop

 

CHANDRAN NAIR’S ADDRESS TO HUXLEY READERS

 

“I am very pleased that my book has been published in Ukrainian under the auspices of the Ukrainian Association of the Club of Rome and with the support of CEO Club Ukraine, Jansen Capital Management, and Huxley magazine. The Sustainable State is a continuation of my first book, Consumptionomics, which challenges Asian companies that believe development and progress can only be achieved by copying the Western model focused on increasing consumption. The focus on increasing consumption and accumulating capital at any cost is damaging the region’s environment and leading to negative consequences, particularly for the poor.

Consumptionomics identified the problem, while The Sustainable State attempts to find a solution. If we cannot practice “consumptionomics” in a world of finite resources, then what should “restrained consumptionomics” look like? I will briefly discuss the challenges facing large developing countries. They are home to millions of people who lack the basic conditions necessary for a decent life: clean water, basic sanitation, quality food, safe housing, healthcare, and so on. Improving living standards is both a political and a moral imperative.

But if developing countries seek to raise those standards by copying the Western model of development, they — and the entire planet — are doomed. Those who talk about sustainable development do not, in fact, have an optimal solution to these problems. Many hope that new technologies and business models will resolve these issues. But they will not. In The Sustainable State, I propose a solution: active government policy can ensure that basic needs are met while simultaneously limiting excessive consumption. This part of the book begins with a real-life case study of how a forest was restored in China’s Youyu County”.

 

The cover of Chandra Nair’s book The Sustainable State

 

KEY THESES FROM CHANDRAN NAIR’S BOOK THE SUSTAINABLE STATE: THE FUTURE OF GOVERNMENT, ECONOMY, AND SOCIETY

 

APOCALYPSE, CHINESE STYLE

 

I

n 2012, I traveled to Youyu County in the northwest of China’s Shanxi Province. One might mistakenly assume that the county, like much of central China, is a dusty semi-desert. After all, coal mining accounts for 90% of the local economy. But Youyu County is not brown — it is green. Its landscape includes forests and grasslands that hold back the nearby deserts. It was not always this way. The county lies near the Ordos Desert, whose expansion was driven by droughts and soil erosion. By 1949, desertification had engulfed three-quarters of its territory. This environmental degradation also had serious consequences for economic development, hampering agricultural activity. Incomes fell to levels of extreme poverty. Everyone who could leave the county did so.

A poem written during those years describes the situation:

 

It was so dark that people needed lamps during the day.
At night, sand would bury your door,
And it would not open in the morning.
One day, the wind brought a sandstorm.
Another day, the rain brought a flood.
The hills became as bare as a monk’s head,
Nine years out of ten, there was no harvest.
Most men left in search of a better life,
Women searched for wild herbs to feed themselves

 
SUSTAINABILITY AS GOVERNMENT POLICY

 

Today, combating desertification is one of China’s environmental policy priorities. Desertification is engulfing vast territories, reducing the area of arable land and polluting the air in Beijing and other cities. China is responding by implementing numerous programs, ranging from reforestation to relocating communities from regions where agriculture is becoming increasingly difficult. The Green Necklace project involves planting forests along the Hebei–Beijing border to combat desertification and industrial pollution. In Youyu, the fight against desertification began back in 1949, when the county’s Communist Party leader was replaced. The new leader declared: “To become rich, we must stop the sandstorms! To stop the sandstorms, we must plant more trees!” This approach made the county a leader in forest restoration.

 

CHINA’S “GREEN PEARL”

 

Subsequently, rapid economic growth brought other symbols of development to the forefront. But the Youyu officials involved in this project remain proud of the results of their work. During my visit to the county, I learned an interesting detail about a former leader: when he was transferred to another region, he took only one “souvenir” with him — an old shovel he had used during his 12 years of public service in Youyu. Today, the barren landscape is a thing of the past. Youyu is known as China’s “Green Pearl”. In 2010, more than 700,000 tourists visited the county. In October 1949, forests covered just 0.3% of its territory, but by 2016, that figure had reached 54%. This exceeds both the national average (21.36%) and the global average (32%). Water and soil erosion have decreased by 60%. Sandstorms last half as long as they once did. Tree planting has become a favorite activity among local residents. Combating desertification has unlocked Youyu’s economic potential. The county has transitioned to “high-quality, highly efficient, environmentally friendly agriculture”.

 
THE FORMULA FOR SUSTAINABILITY: LEADERSHIP AND TRUST

 

Youyu is a striking example not only of environmental protection and the restoration of natural resources. It also demonstrates that achieving sustainable development goals requires government-level reforms and an experimental approach to leadership sustained over decades. The government adopted a reforestation plan that was implemented over more than 50 years by two generations. Party officials became “forest directors”, ensuring widespread public participation in the project. People trusted their leaders and their goals because those leaders were passionately committed to improving life for society as a whole. Unfortunately, examples like this are now virtually impossible to find in developing countries. Could the Indian government restore one of its states in the same way? Or could the Indonesian government restore the forests of Kalimantan, where the climate is favorable for such efforts? Could the United States launch a large-scale reforestation program? Sustainable development goals require us to answer a fundamental question: are countries capable of using the powers of government to achieve sustainability and restore the environment and natural resources?

 

By joining the Huxley friends club, you support philosophy, science and art

 

CORPORATIONS ARE ONLY PRETENDING TO BE “SUSTAINABLE”

 

Throughout my career, I have participated in countless conferences and meetings. And I have always concluded my speeches by expressing the same idea: “Very few people can grasp the scale of the global challenges associated with sustainability. They do not understand the realities that demand uncompromising and uncomfortable decisions. The fight against climate change is perhaps the only exception, but it is merely one part of the sustainability challenge”. The concept of sustainable development is mistakenly understood as environmental protection and increased environmental awareness. This gives the policies of many companies and organizations a superficial and trivial character. Initiatives such as lowering air-conditioning temperatures in offices or Coca-Cola sponsoring a conference on reducing water consumption fall under the banner of “sustainability” only in a formal sense. These organizations employ unsustainable practices within their own operations while encouraging them throughout their production and supply chains. By creating platforms such as the Global Compact, the United Nations has enabled corporations to engage in a charade, pretending to pursue policies of sustainability, fairness, and inclusiveness. Even well-informed UN representatives abandon intellectual honesty for fear of upsetting corporate members of the Global Compact and other advisory boards.

 

SUSTAINABILITY DOES NOT MEAN “BEING GREEN”

 

All sustainable systems are “green”, but not all “green” systems are sustainable. The concept of sustainability is broader than “being green”, which refers to reducing the environmental costs of economic activity, such as those associated with waste disposal. Nowadays, environmental responsibility should be a standard part of everyday practice. Sustainability means managing resources in a way that ensures fair and equal access for everyone. The ability of a system to survive by replenishing resources faster than they are consumed is the defining characteristic of a sustainable economy.

 
SUSTAINABILITY DOES NOT MEAN “DEVELOPMENT”

 

Developed economies have succeeded in meeting the basic needs of their populations, something that remains out of reach for most developing countries. The word “development” is often used as a synonym for high rates of economic growth, even when such growth fails to improve the lives of a significant proportion of the population. Some equate development with modernization along Western lines. Skyscrapers in Shanghai, Kuala Lumpur, or Manila are seen as evidence of progress, despite the appalling poverty that exists in the immediate vicinity of their city centers. Internet connectivity does not reduce the number of people living in poverty or solve the challenges of sustainable development either. Satellite communications connect people, but they cannot provide them with sewage systems, running water, or housing. Even when systems that differ from Western societies demonstrate good results, they are still considered “underdeveloped”. The West urges them to follow its familiar economic and political models, even when such “development” leads to growing inequality. Sustainable development means meeting basic needs without overexploiting resources, thereby preserving the right to life for future generations.

 
THE “INDIAN QUESTION”

 

Today, there is no answer to the “Indian question”: how can India, with a population of 1.2 billion (projected to reach 1.5 billion by 2050), lift hundreds of millions of people out of poverty while remaining sustainable? All known development models lead to excessive resource consumption, environmental pollution, and enormous amounts of emissions and waste. However, India believes it would be unfair to deny hundreds of millions of people the opportunity to approach European and American living standards by adopting the Western approach to development to improve their quality of life. In an ideal world, India would be absolutely right. But in the real world, this presents a challenge for sustainable development: how can developing countries provide a basic standard of living for their populations without destroying the planet? According to the World Bank, 700 million people live on less than US$2 a day. One in ten people lacks access to clean water. One in three does not have access to adequate sanitation. Cities choking on smog and lacking effective waste disposal systems pose enormous health risks to their residents. Deforestation to make way for plantations threatens biodiversity. Groundwater and surface water are contaminated with waste and chemicals. The construction of new power plants and the growing number of cars are turning carbon emissions from a local problem into a global one.

 
THE IDEA OF ALTERNATIVE DEVELOPMENT

 

Countries such as China, India, Indonesia, Nigeria, and Brazil are attempting to raise their populations’ living standards while degrading the environment and depleting natural resources. The only development models available to them are unsustainable and borrowed from the West. At the same time, Western experts are reluctant to discuss this problem because doing so could lead to confrontation over global political and economic issues. As a result, developing countries find themselves at a crossroads: which direction should they take if pursuing Western living standards means social and environmental collapse? Without an alternative understanding of what “prosperity” and “development” mean, this dilemma cannot be resolved.

 


 

Huxley Dossier:

Chandran Nair is the founder and CEO of the Global Institute for Tomorrow.

Until 2004, he served as Chairman of Environmental Resources Management in the Asia-Pacific region. He is a regular speaker at global forums, including the World Economic Forum, Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summits, and Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development events.

He is a member of the Club of Rome and the Royal Society of Arts.

 


When copying materials, please place an active link to www.huxley.media
Found an error?
Select the text and press Ctrl + Enter